Gainesville City Commission names Ed Book as Mayor Pro Tem, asks for more information on automated parking enforcement

The Gainesville City Commission met as the General Policy Committee on October 22

BY JENNIFER CABRERA

GAINESVILLE, Fla. – At the October 22 General Policy Committee meeting, the Gainesville City Commission named Ed Book as Mayor Pro Tem and asked staff for more information about an automated parking enforcement system.


Commissioner Willits steps down as Mayor Pro Tem, nominates Book

At the beginning of the meeting, Mayor Harvey Ward announced that he would have to leave at 2:30, so he asked to move Commission Comment to the beginning of the meeting, and the other Commissioners agreed. 

During Commission Comment, Commissioner Casey Willits said, “I have a few things coming up in the next couple of months [that will] take a little bit of my time. Definitely some home repair, probably some tooth repair… If this Commission is amenable, I would like to step down from being the Mayor Pro Tem, and I would like to nominate Commissioner Ed Book to fill out the rest of his term as Mayor Pro Tem.” Book did not run for re-election and will step down in early January.

Ward said, “I love the idea.” He asked when that should be effective, and Willits said he wanted it to be effective immediately. Book said, “I’m very honored that you would even consider that, so thank you.” The motion passed unanimously, and Book moved to the Mayor Pro Tem chair. 

Advertisement


Automated parking enforcement devices

Debbie Leistner from the Transportation Department spoke about an automated parking enforcement system that had been piloted earlier this year. She said the City’s Parking Enforcement team is small, and it patrols an area of about 1.5 square miles, generally around UF and downtown. She said, “The number of parking spaces on-street are scarce, and there are a lot of infractions, and we’re not able to effectively provide coverage.”

She continued, “Safety violations are a primary concern because they create blockages to bike lanes and crossings. They force people into travel lanes, causing potential conflicts. They affect the operation of some transit routes and block access to transit stops, also forcing people into traffic. Emergency access is also a problem in loading zones, as well, because if a vehicle is taking that space, then a large vehicle has to double-park.”

She said people often park in bike lanes, block access to crosswalks, or park on the street on narrow roads where parking is not permitted, preventing buses from using those roads. 

During the pilot program, 48% of the violations occurred outside of normal enforcement hours, and 41% occurred on the weekends. 



For the pilot program, the City selected the SafetyStick system with a bollard that contains a camera and radar; it takes a photograph of the tag of a vehicle parked in a location where there is a clear parking prohibition, as opposed to an area where permits are required. For example, it could be used in a tow-away zone. The photo is reviewed by a Parking Enforcement Officer and entered into the City’s regular system for violations. The pilot program included four devices at three locations: one at a bus stop, one at a loading zone, and one at a bike lane. No citations were issued during the pilot program.

Leistner said that no other cities in Florida use this type of device, but the City of Albuquerque uses about 158 of these devices. She said staff estimated that each device would generate about $3,000 per year; the vendor supplies the devices, there is no installation cost, and the revenue is shared with the vendor. Leistner said the pilot program did not cost the City anything.

A typical citation would be $34, with a cost-share model of 60/40 (City/vendor) for citations issued or 50/50 for the amount collected. Passport charges a fee of $4.90 to process each citation.

Leistner said staff recommended deploying some units, integrating them with the Passport parking app for citation payments and appeals, testing how the system works by issuing citations, and reporting back to the City Commission. She said an ordinance amendment would be necessary to allow citations to be sent by mail instead of being placed on the windshield of the vehicle.

Ward asked for clarification that the bollards would only be used “in unsafe spaces that are blocking things, and that sort of thing,” and Leistner said that was correct. Commissioner James Ingle asked whether the devices would be used in cases where people pay for parking but don’t leave when the time is up, and Leistner said it would only be in areas where parking is prohibited.

Ingle also asked Leistner to confirm that all of the enforcement is handled in-house and the photos are not transmitted to third parties, and she said there would be provisions in the contract to ensure that.

A vehicle can be towed if five unpaid citations are accumulated

Leistner said that if someone doesn’t pay a citation within 30 days, there is an escalation fee of $16, and if they accumulate three or more unpaid citations over 30 days, the vehicle can be booted; if they accumulate five or more unpaid citations over 30 days, the vehicle can be towed. She said the citations cannot be converted to a moving violation or result in points on a driver’s license.

Leistner said the City issued almost 25,000 parking citations (issued by Parking Enforcement Officers) in Fiscal Year 2026; the City collected about $790,000, and $175,000 is unpaid.

Commissioner Ed Book: “We’re talking about basically towaway zone types of areas for this parking enforcement: a bike lane, a sidewalk, a fire hydrant, or something like that.”

Book said it’s important to differentiate between this system, which takes still photos of vehicles that are parked illegally, and “other camera systems and technology that have been in the media for the last year… We’re talking about basically towaway zone types of areas for this parking enforcement: a bike lane, a sidewalk, a fire hydrant, or something like that.” He asked who would have access to the data, and Leistner said it would be available to the Parking Enforcement Officers and would be housed on the Passport platform.

City Attorney Daniel Nee: “I don’t know anything about this yet. This is relatively new.”

Book asked City Attorney Daniel Nee if he had any concerns with the system, and Nee said, “I don’t know anything about this yet. This is relatively new… I don’t even know if you can issue a citation by mail… Statutes contemplate putting citations on windshields, not delivering them through the mail. Whether we can send out 50% of the fine to a private vendor is also something I’m not sure of. But those are things we’ll look into. That’s the next step in this process.”

In response to a question from Willits, Leistner said the City would have the flexibility to move the units to different locations as needs change.

Ward asked if anyone wanted to make a motion, and there was a long pause, so he said, “Let the record show that we are comfortable with the current situation.”

Commissioner Bryan Eastman said he was willing to explore the program, but he had concerns about being the first Florida city to use it and whether there are any statutory issues.

Interim City Manager Andrew Persons said he was looking for direction on whether to move forward with exploring the various issues. He said the next step would be working with the City Attorney and bringing information back to the Commission before drafting an ordinance.

Motion

Eastman made a motion to “direct staff in the City Attorney’s Office to review the — legal, financial — to review the automated parking enforcement devices and come back with analysis about implementation at that point.”

Commissioner Cynthia Chestnut said she didn’t think they had “enough information to say to staff to proceed in any direction,… so I would be voting against it.”

The motion passed 5-2, with Chestnut and Willits in dissent.

15 Comments

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *