PBA and Sheriff Watson no closer to agreement


ALACHUA COUNTY, Fla. – Sheriff Clovis Watson, Jr., and the North Central Florida Police Benevolent Association (PBA), the organization that bargains for Alachua County Sheriff’s Office (ACSO) deputies, are still unable to come to an agreement regarding their 2020-2022 contract.


The most contentious issue is the ability for deputies to take home agency vehicles. Jody Branaman, PBA President, says all the other Sheriff’s agencies in Florida permit deputies to take vehicles home; Sheriff Watson says he understands that removing this ability will have a “negative impact” on deputies who live over the county line in neighboring counties, but “I must also fulfill my responsibility to the tax-payers of Alachua County.”

The current contract allows deputies to take vehicles home if they live in a county contiguous to Alachua County, as long as their residence is no further than 10 miles outside the Alachua County line.

The proposed contract grandfathers in current employees and allows Sheriff Watson to give case-by-case permission to new hires to drive their vehicles home. Deputies who move after the effective date in the contract (April 28, 2022) and live outside Alachua County will no longer be able to drive their vehicles home. Branaman said the removal of the ability to drive vehicles home was a major factor in the union membership’s vote against the contract last fall and that the current contract is valid through December 31, 2022, so Watson should not be changing the terms as of April 28.

Pay and steps

Under the existing contract, all deputies were supposed to advance one step in the Pay Step Plan and receive a 2.5% pay increase, but those increases never happened. Branaman said they have been implemented and reversed twice, once on October 1, 2021, and once on February 28, 2022. 

Watson is proposing that all deputies forego the step increase in 2021 and instead receive a 3% pay increase, with the Step Plan resuming in 2022. The proposed contract promises that deputies will be paid the 3% raise, retroactive to October 1, 2021, when the contract is ratified. Watson says he is negotiating with the County Commission for bigger raises in the next fiscal year but cannot make any promises until the budget is finalized. Branaman says the language in the proposed contract is unclear about when the step increase will resume in the 2022-2023 fiscal year.


While all other County employees got paid holidays on Good Friday and Juneteenth this year, the lack of a new contract meant that deputies did not get the two additional holidays. Watson is proposing retroactively giving deputies 16 hours of annual leave to compensate them.

Next steps

The PBA still has an outstanding grievance against Sheriff Watson, and that will next be heard in court on July 14. In the meantime, the two sides are holding meetings, and the union will meet tonight to consider whether they want to vote on the proposed contract.

  • With gas at almost 5.00 a gallon I don’t see anyone being able to have a take home car

    • You are aware that our deputies are some of the lowest paid in the state right? Furthermore, their shift begins the instant they leave their driveways which improves response time.

    • It doesn’t cost $5 a gallon. State and local agencies have contracts at preset prices, much less than what is available at the gas station.

  • My ex sister and brother-in-law were Alaucha county deputy’s they used their cars as their personal vehicles taking kids to school going shopping on way from work they both drove unmarked cars just how much more of this goes on yes I did reach it to internal affairs nothing was done about

  • My neighbor directly across the street is an ASO Deputy. Seeing her car return home after every shift is reassuring. It’s sad and speaks volumes that they are among the lowest paid public servants in the state. Like Heather said, the shift begins when the vehicle leaves the driveway, and I might add that the presence of the vehicle while off duty is much appreciated also.

  • I suspect that this wouldn’t be an issue if the Sheriff’s Office were properly funded.

  • Our cop cars in Gainesville and Alachua County have always seemed very new and luxurious compared to cop cars in other similar-sized cities (most of which are not on the verge of financial insolvency like we are). The Sheriff bought a small fleet (five?) of luxury SUVs recently, including one for himself. This is another instance of Grace Marketplace hurting the whole county by sapping resources from the jail and the Sheriff’s department. Stop buying new cop cars all the time and shut down Grace Marketplace – that would be a good start as far as having money for normal things like paying your staff normal wages.

    • There are patrol cars in the Sheriff’s fleet that are seven years old. That is why new cars are purchased every year. The Sheriff’s Office is not replacing the entire fleet every year.

  • >