UF neurologists tout alternate way to treat stubborn vertigo

Press release from UF Health
BY GRACE HUFF
GAINESVILLE, Fla. — For people who experience benign paroxysmal positional vertigo, or BPPV, even a tiny head tilt can suddenly make it feel like the room is spinning wildly.
While BPPV is one of the most common causes of dizziness, it is also highly treatable, often through a series of carefully performed head and body movements known as repositioning maneuvers. BPPV affects an estimated 30% of people older than 60 and 50% of those over 85, ranging from a brief annoyance to a temporary debilitating condition that disrupts daily life.
The Epley maneuver has been a common treatment for BPPV for 45 years. But neurologists at the Norman Fixel Institute for Neurological Diseases at University of Florida Health are highlighting another technique that may deserve a more prominent role in patient care, especially when symptoms persist.
In a recent letter to the editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association, also known as JAMA, Jennifer L. Purks, M.D., and Michael S. Okun, M.D., of the Fixel Institute, along with Dena B. Dubal, of the University of California, San Francisco, discussed evidence that supports using the Semont-plus maneuver as another treatment option for BPPV.
Epley vs. Semont-plus
BPPV occurs when tiny calcium carbonate crystals, called canaliths, become displaced within the inner ear. Certain changes in head position can then trigger brief but intense vertigo episodes. Repositioning maneuvers can move the crystals out of the inner ear. The Epley maneuver has become a widely used first-line treatment for posterior canal BPPV because it is accessible, supported by a compelling evidence base, and can be taught for at-home use.
The Semont-plus maneuver uses a different sequence of movements to reposition the crystals. Named after its creator, Dr. Alain Semont, the maneuver adds a greater head extension and wider body movement to the traditional Semont maneuver.
Evidence from a clinical trial published in JAMA comparing the two approaches found that both performed well, reinforcing that BPPV is highly treatable when the right maneuver is performed correctly on the affected ear.
The study also found a signal that Semont-plus may lead to faster resolution of positional vertigo for some patients, possibly due to more effective clearance of crystal debris due to the patient’s head being dropped below horizontal.
Another option when symptoms persist
The researchers emphasize that the findings do not mean the Epley maneuver should be abandoned. Instead, clinicians may benefit from having multiple effective approaches to select the best fit for the patient. The Epley remains a dependable first-line treatment, including for home use. Semont-plus, however, may be extra helpful when patients experience persistent vertigo after repeated Epley maneuvers or when faster recovery is needed.
“Underutilization of the Semont-plus maneuver is a missed opportunity for our field, and the Semont-plus maneuver should be incorporated in patients who do not improve with repeat Epley maneuvers or have persistent positional symptoms,” Purks said.
The lesser-known maneuver may also offer practical advantages for patients.
“Current evidence demonstrates that the Semont-plus maneuver may be easier to perform in patients with cervical spine or shoulder problems,” Purks said.
Despite this, the authors note that Semont-plus remains underused, even though clinical trials report an initial-visit success rate of 90%.
Limited exposure during clinical training, the physical demands of performing the maneuver, and perceptions of technical complexity may be why that’s so.
Patients can learn both the Epley and Semont-plus maneuvers for at-home use, which can reduce the need for repeated clinic visits.
Purks and colleagues encourage clinicians to broaden their BPPV treatment toolkit.
