Bielarski: Fact or Fiction, Part 2

Letter to the editor
Are GRU utility services outrageously expensive?
Purpose
As the general manager under the Gainesville City Commission for several years and the CEO under the nearly new GRU Authority, I am uniquely qualified to provide perspective on the rhetoric you may be hearing about GRU’s current governance. To help navigate this rocky road, I am writing a series of articles to address subjects that I think need clarification or, in some cases, are simply untrue. If you have specific questions about GRU or want to clear up something you’ve heard, please feel free to email me at bielarskiej@gru.com.
Claim
GRU utility services are outrageously expensive.
Facts:
Key Point #1: The reality is that GRU electric bills have dropped 11% since the formation of the GRU Authority, the utility’s independent board.
As recently as March of 2023, GRU had the highest average residential electric bills in the state. However, since the Authority took over as GRU’s governing board in October 2023, customers have benefited from significant changes to the way GRU conducts business – paying down dramatic levels of debt; declaring no increases in the electric base rates for two consecutive years; and approving modest increases in operating expenses (lower than the cost of inflation). The results have been dramatic.

As reflected on the chart from the Florida Municipal Electric Association (FMEA), GRU’s monthly residential electric bills have fallen from the highest to the 14th-highest in the state and are now within 7% of the state average.

Taking data from the same FMEA source, you can see that since the Authority has been seated, GRU’s residential customer’s average electric bill has fallen from $28 more than the state average to less than $10 more ($9.44).
Even Fitch Ratings Agency, one of the three preeminent bond-rating agencies in the world, now calls GRU’s electric charges “affordable.”
Key Point #2: It’s not only GRU’s electric bills that are more affordable, but its entire basket of services provided are some of the most affordable in Florida.
The following chart shows that, of the major metropolitan areas from Central Florida up through Jacksonville and across to Pensacola, GRU’s combined cost of electricity, water, wastewater, and natural gas is lower than all regions other than Lakeland (Lakeland Electric) and Kissimmee (Kissimmee Utility Authority), which are less than $5 lower.

Summary
It’s a myth that GRU’s utility services are outrageously high. In fact, the numbers reflect affordable rates/bills for all GRU services, unless one’s housing conditions include 1) poor or inadequate wall, roof, and window insulation; 2) low efficiency heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) systems; and/or 3) personal choices in regard to thermostat settings (every 2-degree shift in setting results in an 8% increase or decrease in electric usage).
It’s also a myth that GRU doesn’t care about the financial plight of many of these customers. While GRU offers free home energy surveys to all its customers, we are proud of the opportunities provided for low-income customers to participate in the Low-income Energy Efficiency Programplus (LEEPplus).
Over the past 18 years, GRU has retrofitted 2,413 homes at a cost of $9,716,070. For that investment from GRU, the most vulnerable of our customers have seen an average electric usage reduction of 145 kWh monthly, or 13.9%, saving these customers about $21/month.
GRU CEO Ed Bielarski, Gainesville
The opinions expressed by letter or opinion writers are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of AlachuaChronicle.com. Assertions of facts in letters are similarly the responsibility of the author. Letters may be submitted to info@alachuachronicle.com and are published at the discretion of the editor.
Kudos to GRU and the utility board!
Guarantee Electric rates WILL GO BACK UP, IF THE COMMIE COMMISSIONERS GET CONTROL AGAIN!😢
DO NOT LET THAT HAPPEN!🙏
All I have to say is Big Daddy Eddie B is doing it wrong!!! You are supposed to take money from the underlings we rule over not save them money. All I can think about is all the rainbow crosswalks I could paint and the homeless Ambassadors I could hire if you would just charge the people more and give me the money.
As I’ve mentioned before, my bill has gone down since the State took control of GRU’s profits away from the Clown Commission.
Only an idiot would vote to allow other fiscally incompetent idiots to regain control of GRU profits to fund their personal agendas.
Thanks for the rate relief on the electrical side. Seems to me we have had substantial increases in water and wastewater rates, including the elimination of the winter maximum. Can you provide some details and comparison on that?
Also, maybe in part 4 you could explain the myth that GRU ratepayers, both in and outside the city limits, should subsidize the cost of providing city services? Doesn’t seem logical or rationale that GRU should be profitable, shouldn’t the goal be stability first, then lowest possible rates? There’s really no need to generate millions in surplus to give it to the City to pay day to day expenses, let the ratepayers keep their hard earned money instead.
Keep up the great work, Ed! I know many in the city are thankless for the job you’re doing, but know that you are appreciated by people with a brain.
Agree totally. If it wasn’t for Ed we’d be in bankruptcy court.
But wait your city manager wants the money for “Community First”so she can swindle it lol
BS BIELARSKI.
And, anyone that believes BS Bielarski is a Fool.
Bielarski is a joke !
HOME RULE FOR GRU.
NO GRUAB.
Return, GRU back to the People !
Besides showing ignorance and lack of education, it is just the usual mud slinging. No facts, just mud and rants. Have some more Kool-Aid and take your nap.
You can always tell when the City Manager posts under fake names. Careful about the “impeachment” ma’am we could only hope you might be next!
My GRU electric bill may be going down, but now I can’t afford to pay my property taxes because they are going up.
Fire fee, garbage fee, storm water fee, water fee, waste water fee..
Sales tax are up for education and public spaces wild places housing homeless miscreants in motels…
Grace Mkt bringing increased crime, litter, & vagrants..
Our city is too small to have such a large RTS bus system. ACSB gets a lot of $ and is failing.
Thank you, Ed!
But like NYC, our political leaders only represent 3-5% of the Gainesville population. An oligarchy like that believes they know best and force the other 95% to pay for their ideology pushed by their donors at the ACLUSPLCDNC 👿👹💩🤡👺
Showing no shame after failing to deliver any promised “mind boggling” bill relief after purchasing our depreciated biomass plant for twice what it cost to build, Bielarski rolls out an “analysis” that 1) ignores bundling of City storm water and garbage fees with GRU electric bills, 2) ignores the surcharge on GRU electric bills outside City Limits, 3) ignores pyramiding of taxes and surcharges at or beyond the legal limit, 4) ignores realignment of the tiers that shifted the burden to those using more than 1000kwh in order to support the narrative, 5) ignores the fact that our community avoided the brunt of recent hurricanes, 6) that GRU nonresidential rates remain exorbitant. Here are the numbers for involuntary electric disconnection for inability to pay which Bielarski could care less about: 3/25 2,717, 4/25 3465, 5/25 3,053, 6/25 2,131. These numbers are METERS! The number of people and animals BEHIND these disconnections are unknown.
all of this makes sense. but what makes the bills seem so high when compared to others around the state is all of the City’s charges… refuse, stormwater, taxes, etc. These should be removed from the bill. The City increased refuse charges and GRU pays the price for their increases. Awful.
I live alone on SS in a 1400 sq ft house with a 20 yr old car. My GRU bill was $300 last month wonder what it will be in Aug?
Note the rates of Duke, FPL, etc.
The city and it’s citizens own GRU, not Belarski, the state GOP, the Governor, or county residents. If county residents don’t like it, we should lobby the county to buy it, or negotiate service elsewhere. It is not our business what GRU does with it’s profits nor how the city manages it’s finances, or ownership and democracy are optional and meaningless in the fascist state of Florida.
Actually, it is, Jazz.
I am forced to buy from GRU.
GRU and the city should hear my voice as a consumer.
They should hear all our voices.
Just because I live outside of city limits by 1/4 of a mile doesn’t mean what the city does not affect me.
But hey, if you think deregulation is a good idea I am for it. Because, I would love to have a choice in who I buy power from.
Until then, GRU is going to hear from us.
I was on Clay Electric for over 30 years. I had no idea . . .
So was I Elizabeth, and while I hold no ill will toward Clay (probably doing their best with more limited resources), GRU is significantly better at service, meaning not going out all the time and fixing it quickly when they do. As a builder, I have worked with Clay’s engineers on routing service to new houses and liked those guys.
Gru should hear from you and I Thatguy, but taking it over is not our right. If you want out, the County Commission is where you should focus.
Alachua County has no role in setting utility territories.
Bundaries are negotiated and occassionally traded. As our unified political voice , the county has the most standing and authority to act on our behalf. Unlike the state GOP, it doesn’t have the self dealt authority to take over other governments or their property, but it can lobby on our behalf.
Is our business, isn’t our business…
Are you always that fickle?
It’s in our best interest to know what becomes of GRU profits. Especially if those profits are being pillaged by the City Commission.
Do I need one hurricane clip and a strap, or just the clip? Don’t answer that.
If you don’t live in the city, take it to the county commission and demand change there.
You rightfully have no say over what the city commision and the people of Gainesville vote for doing with GRU profits unless it is illegal.
What a crazy comment. Did Gillum tell u to say that?