Letter: The progressive populist case for single-member districts

Rarely in politics is there such a slam-dunk, air-tight case as there is for single-member districts in Alachua County.

Right now, we have five County Commission districts, each with roughly 40,000 voters. But when we hold elections, the entire county gets to vote for each commissioner. This means that all 200k voters can vote for all five, which renders districts themselves fairly pointless. The “meaty majority” in Alachua County gets to pick all five, and hence we are pretty much guaranteed to get five carbon-copies of each other in terms of policy.

I’m a Democrat. I volunteered for Clinton in ’92, Obama in ’08, and Bernie in ’16. But I also know that single-party control is very bad, regardless of the party. Our elected officials need not trouble themselves with public opinion or actually serving their constituents because they face little to no threat of losing elections. That is partially why we have among the highest energy rates in the state, along with unacceptably high poverty and income inequality.

The entire idea behind having an elected representative is that a “district” has a resident who runs for office and is voted on BY THAT DISTRICT. As it stands today, the 40k voters in each Alachua County district are outnumbered by the 160k voters who do NOT live in their district!

Let’s be honest. Most people against single-member districts do not WANT citizens in outlying areas like Archer/Newberry/Alachua having representation. Sure, they will come up with talking points like “but you have five reps instead of one,” but the truth is they WANT a County Commission with five identical establishment Democrats.

Advertisement

Alachua County is 50% Democrat, 27% Republican, and 23% other. There is no doubt that Democrats should and will always have a majority. But all five seats, in perpetuity? Is that fair? Is that what a representative democracy looks like?

I truly cannot come up with a rational reason to oppose single-member districts, and neither can those who oppose it, outside of preserving the status quo. I urge Alachua County voters to enthusiastically VOTE YES for single-member districts this year. It is just about our last hope at having anything resembling a functioning representative democracy.

Dan Richman, Gainesville

The opinions expressed by letter or opinion writers are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of AlachuaChronicle.com. Letters may be submitted to info@alachuachronicle.com and are published at the discretion of the editor.

10 Comments