Silva: City Commission should listen to the public on zoning changes

Letter to the editor

After its summer break, the Gainesville City Commission has a loaded agenda on Thursday, morning to night, with the millage rate and a zoning ordinance toward the end of the meeting.

A version of the contentious city-wide upzoning proposals of years past is up for votes on Thursday evening. The last time the main proposal came up, in January, some commission members insulted and walked out on constituents who brought questions, experience, and research to the discussion. Disrespect from the dais has been a sad trend in recent years, but maybe this week’s calls for unity will influence friendlier interactions now.

Advocates have promoted upzoning of residential neighborhoods since July 2018 in the name of “missing middle housing” and “affordable housing” (and supposed racial equity), but the blanket upzoning they want gives away City leverage for nothing in return. That happened in 2020 when 4-3 votes did away with single-family zoning by allowing two rental units plus a house of any size, all of them up to three stories and for any amount of rent, on any residential property in the city except those in homeowners associations. State law removed another item from Gainesville development-deregulation proponents’ to-do list last year by banning local occupancy limits.

Advertisement

“EZ” (“exclusionary zoning”) and “IZ” (“inclusionary zoning”) were key aspects of a New York consultant’s assignment in 2020. The EZ proposal of 2022 was contested by City boards, the County Commission, 1000 Friends of Florida, 4,000+ petitioners, and many speakers at public hearings. It passed anyway but was soon rescinded by a new commission. The EZ proposal up for votes on Thursday popped up right away and is not that different; it cuts minimum lot sizes and building setbacks and allows configurations of houses grouped together on properties in residential neighborhoods throughout Gainesville. Like earlier renditions, the proposal lacks data and analysis (and even had a false claim that small houses are currently illegal), and it requires no income, infrastructure, compatibility, or other criteria. Such random upzoning defeats the purpose of zoning to organize growth with some predictability.

However noble or progressive the wording, these proposals in this city, without guardrails, potentially add to speculative development and concentration of ownership for investor profits. Insisting that zoning is the problem ignores the bigger economic forces and upheavals and the City spending spree and utility bills that have made housing more expensive.

The supply-and-demand rationale for upzoning doesn’t hold up either. The previous mayor said, “Gainesville has an overabundance of affordable housing” (Gainesville Sun, July 2017), and the current mayor said he wants 10 times more houses a year demolished by Gainesville code enforcement (commission meeting, August 2023). The city has vacant (14% of residential units in 2022) and underused properties and an ongoing building boom of expensive apartments. The Shimberg Center for Housing Studies found that across Florida, “the state added hundreds of thousands of rental units between 2012 and 2021 but lost units renting for $1,000 or less (2021 $).” It said Florida gained a net 600,000 units above $1,000/month rent and lost 277,000 under $1,000, all adjusted to 2021 dollars. That was before inflation and interest spiked. The math in Gainesville rents skews higher, as well, with the thousands of new units.

The “IZ” item on Thursday’s commission agenda is pitched as a way to reduce rents on some units by granting density bonuses to developers of 10 units or more. Gainesville has offered bonuses for various benefits over the years but had few takers, and housing specialists have long advised that IZ is kind of a wash overall.

While the City government plugs along to enact IZ, the state government in 2023 initiated its Live Local Act, which some cities and counties are scrambling to opt out of. Live Local preempts local zoning and ensures local tax breaks for apartment developments with a proportion of units for tenants with 120% of the area median income (AMI), that is, it preempts commercial and much-needed industrial zoning and makes local taxpayers subsidize market-rate apartments.

For decades already, Gainesville City government has granted tax incentives of millions of dollars for market-rate developments including student apartment complexes, and it plans more in the near future. City Plan Board members have raised concerns about Live Local, but so far it hasn’t had much discussion here. The legislature made some adjustments to Live Local this year, and still cities and counties are opting out to protect their tax bases and their commercial and industrial zoning from further losses.

In short, the Gainesville City Commission would do the City a favor by letting go of theoretical notions propped up by consultants and instead reopening actual public participation in decision-making based on real-world conditions and priceless local experience.

Tana Silva, Gainesville


The opinions expressed by letter or opinion writers are their own and do not necessarily represent the views of AlachuaChronicle.com. Assertions of facts in letters are similarly the responsibility of the author. Letters may be submitted to info@alachuachronicle.com and are published at the discretion of the editor.

10 Comments