“I like to try to cut taxes, but we’ve got a lot of priorities”: Alachua County Commission cuts property tax rate despite Prizzia’s plea

Alachua County Commission Chair Anna Prizzia speaks at the July 11 meeting

BY JENNIFER CABRERA

GAINESVILLE, Fla. – During the evening portion of their July 11 meeting, the Alachua County Commission formally approved a cut in property tax rates for Fiscal Year 2024 despite a plea from Chair Anna Prizzia to leave taxes at the same rate to fund their priorities.

Property tax

County Manager Michele Lieberman proposed the property tax rate decrease on June 14 during her annual budget presentation. Although increases in property values will result in tax increases for most property owners, the County’s property tax millage is now set to decrease for the seventh year in a row, from 7.7662 mills in the current fiscal year to 7.6414 in the upcoming year. The tax rate could potentially be set lower when the board takes its final vote in September, but it cannot be increased without sending out additional notices to taxpayers.

The rollback rate (the rate at which the County would raise the same revenue, given the increases in property values) is 7.1074, which would have raised $4.2 million more than the current fiscal year’s property tax revenue (the increase is mainly due to new construction). The proposed millage rate of 7.6414 mills will raise about $15 million more than the current year’s revenues. The MSTU Law Enforcement millage will remain the same at 3.5678 mills, which will raise about $2.8 million more than the current year.

Advertisement

Commissioner Ken Cornell said, “So, commissioners, we can’t go up, can always go down.” He made a motion to approve staff’s recommendation, and Commissioner Chuck Chestnut seconded the motion.

Chair Anna Prizzia said, “We’ve got a lot of priorities, folks. I get it. I like to try to cut taxes, I like to make things less expensive, but we’ve got a lot of priorities, so we’ve been dumping them on the staff lately. We even had to dip into reserves this year because of a priority, so I’m just bringing that up, just throwing it out there.” 

Cornell replied, “I said that,” and Prizzia said, “I know, but you moved staff’s recommendation.” Prizzia then called for the vote, which was 4-0 in favor of Cornell’s motion, with Commissioner Mary Alford absent. Cornell said to Prizzia, “You voted for staff’s recommendation,” and Prizzia replied, “You know. I’m gonna go with the flow.”

Stormwater

In her June 14 budget presentation, Lieberman recommended an increase of $10 per equivalent residential unit (4,011 square feet of impervious area) in the stormwater fee. Commissioner Marihelen Wheeler made a motion to adopt staff’s recommendation, and Chestnut seconded the motion. In response to a question from Prizzia, Lieberman said the increase is needed to cover salary increases. 

Prizzia said, “We need to do more about stormwater than just fees and just thinking about big holes in the ground. I think we’re seeing more and more, as climate change happens, the flooding that’s really happening with intensifying rain storms and increased impervious surfaces, and I think our Vulnerability Analysis and our upcoming Climate Action Plan is going to be a really important process and opportunity for us to begin to delve into the policies and decision-making around that, including things like changing our requirements around impervious surfaces and things like that.”

The board voted 4-0 to approve the stormwater fee increase.

Solid waste assessment

The solid waste increases vary based on container sizes and other factors and can be found in the table below.

Chestnut made a motion to accept staff’s recommendation, and Chestnut and Wheeler both seconded it. The board voted 4-0 in favor of the motion.

Fire assessment

Lieberman did not recommend an increase in the fire assessment fee in her budget presentation. Cornell made a motion to approve staff’s recommendation, and Chestnut seconded it. The board voted 4-0 in favor of the motion.

39 Comments